Fleet management is a complex dance of logistics, operations, and, most importantly, compliance. Adequate trucking compliance is not just about ticking the right boxes; it’s a fundamental aspect of public safety, driver welfare, and operational efficiency.
To ace this crucial part of fleet management, the tool you choose is just as important as the strategy you implement.
For the fleet compliance manager looking to optimize operations while adhering to stringent compliance requirements, this is your roadmap to success.
The role of TMS in modern fleet management
Before we plunge into the specifics, it’s pivotal to understand how a TMS can revolutionize your fleet management approach. A TMS isn’t just a digital logbook; it’s the central hub where crucial data about your fleet’s activities, performance, and DOT fleet compliance come together.
This consolidation of information is more than mere convenience — it’s a strategic imperative.
Modern fleet software solutions offer a bouquet of features that streamline everyday operations and ensure regulatory requirements are met without any loopholes.
From real-time tracking to intelligent alerts that preempt regulatory violations, these systems deliver the kind of precision and efficiency that can significantly lower operational costs and potential liabilities.
Quicklook: 6 best TMS options for fleet compliance
- Best for compliance management and tracking: Rose Rocket
- Best for anticipating regulatory changes: Truckbase
- Best for adaptability and analytics: Trimble
- Best for driver management: Motive
- Best for user-friendly interface: Samsara
- Best for last-mile deliveries: Onfleet
Comparing the best TMS for fleet compliance management
Rose Rocket
Rose Rocket stands out with its dedication to driver-specific compliance tracking.
Their TMS doesn’t just monitor fleets; it provides insights into individual driver performance through an innovative driver scorecard. This feature allows fleets to identify patterns of non-compliance and address them at the source.
Additionally, their automated reporting system ensures you’re always ready for any regulatory audit.
Best for: Compliance management and tracking
Features
- Historical lane data algorithms
- Dwell time reporting
- BI tools for evaluating profitable regions/customers
- Uses AI and machine learning algorithms to analyze trucking market data
- Ingests and evaluates historical carrier rate data
- Assesses trucking freight rates, volumes, equipment lanes, driver networks
- Full trucking and logistics platform suite
Benefits
- Increases revenue per mile through better truck lane planning
- Reduces empty miles and backhaul costs
- Real time margin insights
- Improves lane utilization and carrier network optimization
Disadvantages
- Requires training for full value realization
- Requires extensive fleet truck service data to ensure algorithms are trained well
Pricing: Try it for free here
Truckbase
Truckbase’s TMS is not just about staying on top of compliance; it’s about spearheading a proactive approach. The system’s AI-powered predictive analytics can warn you of potential compliance issues before they even occur, based on a deep analysis of historical and real-time data.
With Truckbase, fleet managers can equip themselves with the foresight needed to adapt swiftly to any changes in regulations. This ability is a game-changer since being proactive in compliance can save significant sums that might otherwise be lost in penalties and operational downtime.
Best for: Anticipating regulatory changes
Features
- Mobile app for driver schedules and document uploads
- Customized solutions
- AI-powered load creation
Benefits
- Suitable for small fleets and can scale with your growing operations
- Dedicated account manager for onboarding and support
Disadvantages: No transparent pricing
Pricing: Contact Truckbase for details
Trimble
Trimble’s TMS is a seasoned player in the industry, known for its robust features and adaptability. The system is a perfect fit for those with existing fleet management systems, as it seamlessly integrates to provide an additional layer solely focused on compliance.
Trimble’s analytics tool is a standout feature, offering actionable insights gleaned from your fleet’s data. It’s not just about tracking; it’s about using that data to make informed decisions that lead to better compliance practices and, consequently, an optimized fleet.
Best for: Adaptability and analytics
Features
- Fuel price tracking
- System alerts
- Geofencing
Benefits
- Real-time vehicle tracking
- Reduce driver error with live tracking and feedback
- IFTA fuel tax data
- Driver vehicle inspection reports (DVIR)
- Fuel use reporting and analysis
- Engine status reports
Disadvantages
- Expensive upfront hardware costs
- Relatively complicated installation
Pricing: $1,200 upfront for hardware with plans starting at $43 per month
Motive
Motive’s TMS is defined by its emphasis on real-time monitoring and tactical efficiency. The GPS tracking and geofencing capabilities ensure that your fleet is always in compliance with prescribed routes and safety regulations.
Motive’s customizable dashboard allows fleet managers to focus on the compliance metrics that matter the most to their fleet operations. This tailored view makes compliance tracking more efficient and relevant, saving time and eliminating unnecessary distractions.
Best for: Real-time visibility and customization
Features
- AI-assisted, real-time safety warnings for drivers
- Automated driver coaching
- Virtual geofenced parameters aid in vehicle and cargo theft recovery
- Real-time GPS fleet tracking and location history records prevent unauthorized vehicle use
- Fuel monitoring
- Dashboard view for fleet tracking
Benefits
- Improved safety compliance
- Reduced fuel usage
- Safer roads
- Decreased coaching time for safety managers
- Improved risk management
Disadvantages: Issues with freezing apps or getting stuck in drive mode
Pricing: Free trial; contact Motive for details
Samsara
Samsara’s standout feature is its intuitive and user-friendly interface. With a platform that’s highly accessible and easy to adopt, it helps stakeholders across the business — not just IT or fleet management — engage with compliance tracking, making it a team effort.
Best for: User-friendly interface
Features
- Fleet maintenance
- Route planning
- Fuel management
- Delivery scheduling and management
- Trailer tracking
- Dash cams
- Real-time vehicle diagnostics
- Compliance
Benefits
- Excellent value
- Strong functionality
- Great customer support
- Easy to use
Disadvantages
- Some users report bugs, but customer service is responsive
- When new updates are released, app may slow down for a few days
Pricing: Complete a company questionnaire and schedule a demo to learn more.
Onfleet
Onfleet harnesses the full potential of their TMS to optimize driver productivity and enhance customer service. Their dedication to trucking company compliance tracking may be at the core, but they also prioritize improving customer satisfaction through efficient delivery compliance as a significant bonus.
Their TMS streamlines various aspects of driver productivity, such as route planning, vehicle maintenance scheduling, and real-time monitoring. By automating these tasks, Onfleet allows drivers to focus on their primary responsibility of making timely and safe deliveries.
Best for: Customer service
Features
- Automated dispatch
- SMS notifications
- Integrations with other vehicle management systems
- Fleet tracking
- End-to-end route planning
- Communication
- Analytics
Benefits
- Easy onboarding process
- Driver app available for iOS or Android
- Drag-and-drop functionality
- Add and delete tasks with ease
Disadvantages:
- System may be unavailable during maintenance periods
- Somewhat limited analytics
- Limited data entry fields
Pricing: Launch for $500 per month, scale for $1,150 per month; 14-day trial
Decision-making process
Choosing the ideal fleet compliance software for your fleet is a decision that warrants careful consideration. Here are the key factors to evaluate before making your choice.
Scalability: Is the TMS solution scalable to accommodate your fleet’s growth? You don’t just need a system that fits your current operational size, but one that can evolve with your business. Cloud-based TMS platforms are often a good choice for expanding businesses.
Support and training: How comprehensive is the support and training provided? A robust TMS is of little use without proper training and ongoing support to maximize its utility within your organization.
Cost and ROI: Pricing of TMS solutions can vary, so it’s important to conduct a cost-benefit analysis to determine the Return on Investment. A higher initial cost may be justified by the savings and enhanced efficiency the system could provide.
Integration with existing infrastructure: Many fleets may already have telematics systems or other software in place. The TMS you choose must integrate smoothly with your current infrastructure to avoid disruption and data silos.
Customization: Each fleet’s compliance needs are unique, and a one-size-fits-all approach rarely works. Ensure the TMS allows you to customize features to meet the specific compliance requirements of your fleet.
Regulatory breadth and depth: Finally, assess how knowledgeable and how frequently the TMS updates its databases to ensure that the system is covering all relevant and changing compliance aspects.
Explore the power of a robust TMS
In the high-stakes game of fleet management, the right tools are those that not only make your job easier but help your business thrive.
Good fleet management software is more than just trackers or data collectors, they are partners in your commitment to compliance, efficiency, and safety. Your fleet health is dependent on it.
It’s time to move beyond basic fleet management and adopt a system that aligns with your vision for your fleet. Make the right choice, and watch as your fleet not only moves but excels.
FAQ
Compliance in the trucking industry refers to adhering to the various regulations and laws set forth by governing bodies, such as the Department of Transportation (DOT). It involves following rules related to vehicle maintenance, driver qualifications, hours of service, and other safety standards to ensure the safe operation of commercial vehicles.
All companies and individuals involved in the operation of commercial motor vehicles in interstate commerce must comply with DOT regulations. This includes truck drivers, motor carriers, and other entities engaged in the transportation of goods or passengers across state lines.
Yes, the trucking industry is considered a high-risk business due to the inherent dangers associated with operating large commercial vehicles on public roads. The potential for accidents, injuries, and liability claims is significant, making it essential for trucking companies to prioritize safety and compliance with regulations.
Sign up for a FreightWaves e-newsletter to stay informed of all news and trends impacting supply chain careers and operations.